Showing posts with label meta. Show all posts
Showing posts with label meta. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 2, 2008

Discourse in Light Novels??!!

Potential future topic:

The reaction to American fiction in Japanese fiction, including responses, re-imaginings, and adaptations. Inspiring example is the high fantasy genre parody of The Slayers in novel format, coming out of a sudden glut of DnD-esque fantasy literature/light novels in the nineties.

Monday, December 1, 2008

Two Modes of Film

Essentially we can break down the types of documentaries on American and British Television into two modes; Japan as Foreign Interest and Japan as Foreign Spectacle. While these are not mutually exclusive modes for these documentaries, indeed, they cross over quite often, they are the dominant modes of discourse within these sets of programmes. Though my purview is limited to the last ten years, to documentary easily found with entries on their respective websites, and to availability, I believe they are representative of the documentaries that are shown on these public television venues on Japan. At the very least, the majority of the discourse falling into certain modes across these limited number of documentaries is representative of a discourse trend that is worth looking at.

Saturday, November 29, 2008

The Hierarchy of Choices When Showing Documentary on Public Television

I believe one of the most important elements in the dissection of the documentary is the various levels of choice that an individual program must go through before it is displayed to the viewing public. There is the level of the individual film makers, who create the piece, on what they want to create or who will fund what subject matters and presentations. There is the top level of PBS (considering the American hierarchy), that holds most of the money distribution, and decides what sort of programmes to fund or buy. There's the government pressures involved on what sort of topics or perspectives gain presidence when using grants, etc, which often have guidelines for their use. As MM sensei brought up for my presentation, there are the pressures of the foreign governments and grants involved in their use, and the host country in what the film maker may 'access'. Then there is the local station, trying to gauge what the host community will most 'appreciate'.

In all of these decisions leave an evidence of discourse upon the Documentary Film on the Topic of Japan. Intersections with American Foreign Policy, in other words, things of American Interests. History that focuses on the time period of christian mercenaries entering into Japan, despite the apparently thematic focus upon 'ancient pre-Westernized' Japan in terms of typical cultural artifacts of the Samurai culture, etc. Then the 'spectacle of culture', the wacky and weird that titillates interest. Why do we approach Japan this way? Why is this sort of treatment of subject the only times we see Japan in Public Telelvision? Because someone thought that this would be 'educational', that this would be 'useful' to the audience/the company. Yet we do not see other treatments of the topic of Japan. We do not see the history of Japan, when there is not also a focus upon some key Chrysanthemum Sword concept, or an important Western Perspective point from which to 'not alienate' (I argue this is something of a weak idea) the audience, because otherwise the audience could not possibly relate to something so foreign.

Part of the question isn't just 'what are these documentaries saying', it's 'someone decided that these are the specific programs worth the 'viewers money'. If they are trying to, on a certain level, play to the forces that would put out the money for these programmes--the funding viewers, the funding acadamia, the funding governement, the fundiing company--then these choices reflect what they think these groups want, which reflects how they think it's appropriate to interact with the idea of 'Japan'.

Monday, November 10, 2008

PBS: Some Thoughts on the Effect of Viewer Appeal on Public Broadcasting Media

Public Broadcasting sustains itself on a combination of foundations, donations, and more specifically, viewer donations. According to current.org, Public Broadcasting grew out of University broadcasting on Radio waves in America, way way back. Since, it has retained a strong tie to the Academic world. Strong appeal to consumers is necessary since the broadcasting can be supported up to 20 percent in revenue through the donation drives. Therefore, the programs must rely upon the 'innate worth' perceived by the audience, Academics working with foundations, and companies who want a by-line with the programs and also donate money to certain works. The lack of commercials is supposed to create a 'free zone', but I do not see this zone as free of influence from political, cultural, and Academic pressures the way I might have five years ago. While there is certainly a certain amount of freedom without the commercial drive, we cannot assume everything we see is 'educational and unbiased.'

Much in the same vein as the supposedly neutral 'encyclopedias' that Said speaks on in Orientalism, the documentary is supposed to be a free zone for commentary. Yet there are still heavy overtures of certain discourses. Japan-o-rama, when combined with a WWII educational video for soldiers, is the inspiration for this project. In both, I saw a strong attempt at authority and yet a flimsy actual product, rather biased. Johnathon Ross is popular at the BBC, evidenced by the fact he has three series, one which ran in chunks of episodes for three seasons, at current, and his work is rather clear evidence of Orientalist discourse still alive in modern, pop and trendy documentary. More serious documentary, on terms of the newsreel, have a much more cut and dry, neutral position, but evidence of their home political climate is still very strong. See Japan's About Face as well as Campaign. Then you have the historical and 'traditional culture' documentary, which take all of the incense smoke images of old Japan, combine them with jidaieki visuals, and make a play out of the events. Academia's influence is very strong in the latter two, I feel, while the more pop culture documentary is often taken on by the amatuer, the non-Academic, and have a more distilled version of current 'popular' impressions from Britain and America about Japan.

Some Priliminary Thoughts on Public Television Documentaries about Japan

I'm pretty sure one of the things behind the discourse in Documentaries is the easy push button for viewer recognition. Using short-cuts of wide-spread held images of the concepts or place being addressed to communicate information, instead of focusing on the reality of these images, or addressing their high levels of constructed meaning. In a way it is a cheap shot used to communicate to the audience, either a sense of place, time, or object, or as a dramatic, interest creating ploy to make the viewer watch by playing on the long-held discourse of Asia as exotic, distant, intriquing, interesting. If the place is exotic, we want to learn more about the 'strange, foreign ways'. However, not all documentaries use these sorts of ploys. There are also political factors, such as the sensitivity of the Atom Bomb, the American Occupation, etc that for an American audience may be elided or not mentioned in a sort of memory open space. I haven't decided how much of this seems to be a sort of political pressure in not wanting to create a controversy that may prevent the documentary from showing (since we are talking about public television), or not wanting to bring up or get into often complicated issues. (Am I giving too much credit there?)

//edit

There seem to be certain dominant aesthetiques in (recent, public television, focused) documentary on Japan--there is the super pop tech bright light, there is the old style jidaieki drama style, and then the more straightforward 'is as is' style.

///Edit

Also, how much of the aesthetique is appropriation of existing aesthetic in the culture viewed to create Theme in the documentary, how much is use of inner cultural signs for the topic, and how much is just cheese?